Already an Angel? You can become a VC, and we'll invest in your fund. Learn how September 1.
Save My Free Seat
Previous Post
Next Post
1

Asked by

Community Member

on

in

General

Deal-by-deal vs whole-of-fund distribution waterfall in Cornerstone: what's the practical trade-off for emerging managers?

Section 3.2 of the Cornerstone LPA offers two bracketed options for the interim distribution waterfall: Deal-by-Deal Distribution (Carried Interest is paid out investment-by-investment once that specific investment returns its own capital) versus Whole-of-Fund Distribution (100% of distributions go to LPs first until they've recouped their entire aggregate Capital Contributions across all investments, before any Carried Interest is paid on any deal). For an emerging manager raising a first fund: (1) which structure do institutional or anchor LPs typically expect or push for, and why? (2) what is the real economic/timing difference for the GP - does deal-by-deal let the GP get paid carry much earlier even if later deals in the portfolio go on to lose money? (3) is a GP clawback (Section 6.4.2) more likely to actually get triggered under a deal-by-deal structure than under whole-of-fund?
1 See in Base
0

Answered by

Community Member

on

- **Institutional / anchor LP preference:** usually **whole-of-fund (European waterfall)**, especially for Fund I. It is more LP-friendly, simpler to diligence, and reduces the risk of the GP receiving carry before overall fund performance is proven.
- **Economic / timing difference:** yes, **deal-by-deal (American waterfall)** can pay GP carry earlier on early winners, even if later deals lose money. The trade-off is mostly **timing**, not ultimate entitlement, because later underperformance can require giveback.
- **Clawback risk:** yes, **clawback is materially more likely to be triggered under deal-by-deal** because carry can be distributed before total fund results are known.
- **Practical point for emerging managers:** anchor LPs often view whole-of-fund as stronger alignment and lower admin complexity.

Reference:
- https://decilegroup.com/articles/vc-fund-accounting

Join VC Lab

Raising your first fund? VC Lab has helped launch 950+ venture firms, with no fees and no equity taken. The average Start Fund reaches first close in 58 days.
Apply Now